I’ve gone and done something rather rash

A second hand PC – £250 – £300

First of all, only the gfx card I’m buying is second hand, and that’s only because I can’t be bothered to wait for a new one to appear at the same price again, which will happen within a few days. I hesitated yesterday and missed one on ebay brand new for less money than I paid for the one I got today, and I also missed that I could’ve got one on overclockers today for about a fiver more than I paid. The components I quoted earlier, in response to your first post, were all new as well.

No contest! Its each to their own! I like consoles because they are more social, easier to use the way I want to use it, and less intense

Of course it’s each to their own, for example in my own experience PC’s have been much the more socialable platform, but I’ll accept more people have a console in their living room than a PC and so they’re used more often socially. Generally speaking I find console games, which don’t have some novelty WII type factor, just as unsociable as most PC games, and I try to avoid anything computer related when out somewhere or have people round. There are certain types of games which lend themselves better to social situations, but even these are mostly best played with 4 or less people in the room. Champ Man, GTA, trackmania, poker, are a few PC examples from my uni days which were popular over a few smokes.

I completely disagree that PC games are more intense than console games, except maybe FPS which are more forgiving on consoles, though even then intensity’s relative to what you’re used to. Maybe it’s just the wrong word you chose, but it’s not an intense experience I’m after when it comes to games, it’s a challenge, and one problem I have with certain genres on consoles is that it’s like looking back 5 -10 years to what PC games were once like in terms of AI. If I’d started off playing consoles these days, I’d probably love them, and laugh at the PC geeks with their word processing prowess, but in starting with PC’s I’ve seen the best computers have to offer, and can’t take a step down from it. For these reasons I have always wondered how PC gamers here have drifted over to consoles, but having said that, the only people who’ve not drifted back to PC’s for FPS, have cited cost as the main barrier.

the original post was mentioning that PCs are the same price as consoles and this simply isnt true

In the OP I said that my outlay on this was in the region of what I’d expect to spend on a console. My outlay is going to be at most £210 but hopefully under 200 if I can find a buyer for anything other than my GFX card, which is more or less sold already. Regardless of that though, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to think even £250 is an unrealistic figure for the cost of a console, and I’m sure that a console would be recommended to anyone with that kind of budget.

Take the XBox arcade for example –

£100 for the console fine, but what else are you probably going to need?
– Will it work wirelessly if you’ve not run a cable directly into it? Nope, and I believe that’ll cost you £70 to fix, although correct me if I’m wrong.

– Will it be any good socially? Nope, only one controller, which will cost £30-40 to fix.

That’s you already up to £200, and you’ve not even bought any games, each of which you can buy £10-20 cheaper on the PC, so any cost advantage is lost in 2 or 3 purchases.

Given that the Xbox Arcade is a budget model, the cost argument isn’t looking too strong here.

I don’t know enough about the PS3 to comment on figures for second hand consoles, but even at £110 you’re 6-10 game purchases away from catching up with my current outlay, and I’m sure that at £110 it wouldn’t come with many controllers.

what psu you running on that rig alzir ?

Mine is 600w, which I’ve been assured will be enough for what I’m planning to run off it. I’m not sure what the minimum PSU would be for it though, but when answering Turk’s question yesterday I even spotted a new 750w psu on ebay for £20.

I cant help to draw back to the point that you are comparing the cost of second hand PC equipment

Once again, I’m not. I’m comparing new PC components with console components. You’re at work, so I’ll let you off with any “read my post” comments, but I have already tried to clear that misconception up in the first paragraph of my last post.

Also factoring in money saved through selling old kit? Really? Ok… I sold my PS2 for £40… suddenly my £110 PS3 is £70.

No, the calcuations in the last post were all based on £250 cost, rather than my own outlay. I thought the final sentence below would make that clear.

My outlay is going to be at most £210 but hopefully under 200 if I can find a buyer for anything other than my GFX card, which is more or less sold already. Regardless of that though, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to think even £250 is an unrealistic figure for the cost of a console,

However – the most important point is that you are comparing the cost of playing a game online for a PC with playing a game with mates in your living room on aconsole… A more fair comparrison would be MP gaming on both over the internet (where you dont have to buy a second controller), and comparing MP gaming with mates in the same room (where you are surverly limited on the PC – either sharing a keyboard for bomberman type games, or buying controllers for each person at additonal cost – either cheaply for shit, or expensively for the good stuff).

Several points here.

First, any comparison I’ve made has been with the audience here in mind, because you can do either platform cheaper if you’re really not that into games. I’ve been trying not to make too many assumptions, and have based most of the costings on what I’d expect to need if I was to get into consoles myself, and this includes XBox Live/whatever as well as an extra controller. Considering that anyone here would have had to have been quite heavily into gaming to have bothered joining XDC, I would be surprised if these were not on most peoples list of prerequisites when considering the cost of a console. It’s also worth noting that, while I’ve not yet made a big deal out of the internet subscription for Xbox Live (for example), the annual cost of that is surely around the cost of a controller?

I really don’t want to get bogged down arguing every little point in this argument because, as you’ve said yourself, it boils down to a case of each to their own. You can do everything with a PC that you can do with a console, and any social aspect really just depends on how you have your rig setup at home. Each to their own pretty much covers every argument we can come up with, but we have a group here where everyone has had some quality PC gaming experience, and where cost is often cited as the main reason why some have adopted consoles as their main gaming platform. If the console experience is what floats your boat, I’m not trying to sink you, but if you look at most arguments in this thread, people are really just defending their decision to chose a particular medium, and what’s the point? Most of us know the differences between the two, as well as knowing what to expect for your money when buying a console. Most people here probably also have both a PC and console at home, which makes it even more pointless. There are some though who are still interested in PC gaming, but for whom cost is still a barrier in keeping up with latest games. As I have been one of them for the past 12-18 months, I’m just keen to point out a solution before anyone is forced to alter what their “own” is on grounds of cost.

Ass hat.

lol does that last post count as a pound to children in need?

Definite sarcasm and some abuse at the end, even if it’s only there for comic effect 🙂